Members of the Brooklyn District Grand Lodge who had the distinctive honor to serve the office of District Grand Masters from the founding of the District in 1934 to 2013 are as follows:
- Hon. Isaacs N. Clarke
- Hon. Charles B. Peter
- Hon. Septimus Sawney
- Hon. Sydney P. Wildman
- Hon. Alphaeus J. Nimrod 1978-1980
- Hon. Alfred Boatswain 1980-1984
- Hon. Winston T. Gaskin 1984 – 1988
- Hon. Ancil. J. Harding 1988 – 1994
- Hon. Edgar Craigg 1994 – 1998
- Hon. Jerome Burke 1998 – 2002
- Hon. Orton Guy 2002 – 2006
- Hon. Denzil Clarke 2006 -2010
- Hon. Joel Jack 2010 – 2012, 2012 – 2014, 2014 – Leave of Absence May 2015
- Hon. David Williams 2015 – 2016 Pro-Temp, 2016 – 2018, 2018 – 2020
- Hon. Daniel Roden 2018 to 2022
- Hon. Myrthland Ince 2022 to Present